Could a Hypothetical Deepfake Scandal on Election Eve Threaten Democracy?

AI-generated Image
Image Credit: Jacky Lee

Picture a scenario where, on the eve of the November 4 election, a sophisticated deepfake video goes viral across major social media platforms like X, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook. This fabricated footage shows a presidential candidate making offensive remarks about minorities, women, individuals with disabilities, and Southern residents. Although entirely fictitious, the shocking and provocative nature of the video could sway voter opinion dramatically, posing a significant threat to the integrity of the electoral process.

[Read More: AI's New Frontier: Influencing Global Elections]

Real-World Implications and Past Incidents

The scenario is not purely hypothetical. Earlier in the 2024 election cycle, a similar incident occurred when a deepfake video mimicking Vice President Kamala Harris was disseminated by tech mogul Elon Musk on his platform, X. The video falsely attributed derogatory statements to Harris, blending genuine campaign visuals with AI-generated audio to create a convincing yet deceptive portrayal. Although Musk later clarified the video’s satirical intent, the initial spread underscored the tangible threat deepfakes pose to political campaigns and voter trust.

[Read More: Elon Musk's Shared Video Sparks Controversy and Concern]

Legislative Landscape: State Laws and Pending Bills

In response to the rising menace of deepfakes, twenty U.S. states have enacted laws prohibiting the creation and distribution of such manipulated media without clear labelling. These regulations aim to ensure that audiences can easily identify synthetic content, thereby mitigating its potential to deceive. States like Alabama and Florida have introduced specific legislation targeting the use of deepfakes in political advertising, mandating disclosures and criminalizing unauthorized image manipulation. Additionally, forty states are actively considering similar measures, reflecting a nationwide effort to curb the misuse of deepfake technology in elections.

[Read More: EU Becomes the First Country to Enact Comprehensive AI Law!]

Advocacy and Calls for Federal Action

Despite significant state-level initiatives, federal legislative progress remains sluggish. Robert Wiseman, head of Public Citizen, a consumer advocacy group, has highlighted the urgent need for comprehensive federal regulations. He emphasizes that without swift federal intervention, the proliferation of deepfakes could undermine democratic processes. Wiseman and his organization have appealed to the Federal Election Commission to establish clear rules addressing deepfake technology, arguing that existing protections are insufficient to combat the sophisticated nature of modern synthetic media.

[Read More: Shaping the Future: Taiwan's Pioneering Draft AI Law to Safeguard Innovation and Society]

About the Public Citizen

Public Citizen was established in 1971 in Washington, D.C. by consumer advocate Ralph Nader and a group of activists and lawyers. The organization was created to promote consumer rights, government accountability, and corporate responsibility, aiming to empower citizens in the democratic process and protect them from corporate influence in politics. Over the years, Public Citizen has expanded its focus to address a wide range of issues, including healthcare, trade, and environmental protection, while maintaining its commitment to advocating for consumer rights and democratic integrity.

[Read More: Navigating the AI Frontier: Why Existing Regulations May Be Enough for Australia]

Global Concerns and Domestic Risks

While international interference in elections through misinformation has been a recognized issue since 2016, domestic threats from deepfake technology present an even more immediate danger. Wiseman points out that domestic political operatives across the spectrum may exploit deepfakes to manipulate voter perceptions, regardless of ethical considerations. The ease of access to deepfake creation tools exacerbates this risk, making it a formidable challenge for maintaining fair and transparent elections within the United States.

[Read More: Power of AI in Politics: Iran's Push for AI-Driven Voter Mobilization]

Social Media Platforms’ Defensive Measures

In anticipation of deepfake threats, major social media companies and AI platforms have implemented robust policies to protect electoral integrity. Platforms like Midjourney, YouTube, OpenAI, and Meta have introduced measures to detect and label AI-generated content, enforce strict guidelines against deceptive political advertising, and promote transparency. These companies employ advanced detection technologies and encourage user vigilance to identify and report misleading content, striving to create a safer online environment during critical election periods.

[Read More: Unleashing Creativity with AI: The Midjourney Experience]

Source: Fox 5 Washington DC